Hotline: 0906 779982Tiếng Việt

A sophisticated scam using an ordinary logistics trick

The incident below shows the seller has cheated his buyer sophisticatedly and perfectly using a popular and simple logistics trick: Switch B/L.

The incident below shows the seller has cheated his buyer sophisticatedly and perfectly using a popular and simple logistics trick: Switch B/L

The incident

At the beginning of 2018, Enterprise A in Hanoi imported from a Singapore trader a batch of scrap iron, type ISRI 210-211 (US standard) packed in 200 40-foot containers. The price was USD 410/t, according to CFR Incoterms 2010 Hai Phong Port. The contract stipulated that the percentage of impurities did not exceed 0.5%. If the percentage was exceeded, the Seller would be fined at USD 50/MT. Regarding the term of inspection at the port of destination, knowing for sure the Buyer would complain about the quality of the goods, the Seller imposed a very strict rule: within one week after the unloading, the inspection of the entire shipment had to end and on the basis, the Buyer would have the right to complain. Unfortunately, the Buyer did not discover this unusual tie during the contract negotiation. Later, through investigation, the new buyer discovered the shipment had been purchased by a Singapore trader from a European iron and steel scrap yard owner to resell them at the above price. Actually, they did not buy the scrap iron ISRI 210-211 as specified, but another type of extremely low quality.

After the first shipment of 10,000 tons arrived, the Buyer randomly selected a few containers for quality inspection and found most of them were impurities and the percentage of impurities was up to 37%-38%, or even 40% in some containers. Due to the poor quality, it took nearly 4 months for the inspection company to finish their work by manual method with the rate of random selection of a number of containers according to the custom of importing scrap in Vietnam. The Buyer immediately informed the Seller about the goods status and asked them to send a representative to Vietnam to review, resolve and also request to suspend the next shipment delivery if the goods were of the same quality. However, the Seller had no replies at all. After consecutive days of urging, the Seller admitted the shipment was bought from a scrap yard owner in Europe and then resold them to the Buyer in Vietnam. They thus asked the Buyer to authorize them to complain the European Scrap Owner. The odd offer certainly was not accepted by the Buyer in Vietnam: the contract clearly stipulated the Singaporean trader is the Seller and the Buyer does not need to know any third party at all. Having no choice, the Buyer informed they would initiate a lawsuit at a commercial arbitration agency having been selected by the two parties in the contract to claim damages of more than USD 1m plus nearly VND 20bn of related fees. On the other hand, the Buyer also asked the Vietnam’s court to order the Bank to open an L/C in Hanoi to blockade and suspend payments. Before filing a lawsuit, the Buyer had to spend a lot to inspect the goods, although the number of goods inspected was about 20% of the containers. It was also noted that because the percentage and garbage in the shipment was extremely higher than usual, the inspection could be carried out manually only. And with the method, it would take over 2 years to inspect the entire shipment of 10,000 tons. Therefore, it was impossible to inspect 100% of the shipment.

After lengthy litigation sessions, the Seller kept the argument the Buyer did not inspect 100% of the containers within a week after the unloading to refuse compensation. They also pretended they had sent representatives to Europe to check and complain about the quality of goods with the yard owner there. In the final litigation session, the Buyer, after having contacts with the owner of the European scrap yard, unexpectedly presented contract evidence and other relevant ones that the Seller bought iron scrap of Europe’s E-46 quality- which has lower quality, not of the U.S’s ISRI 210-211. Obviously, everyone knows ISRI 210-211 scarp is far different from E 46 in terms of both quality and price. In fact, the Seller had bought them at USD 310/T and resold them to Vietnam party at USD 410/T with the CFR Incoterms 2010, Hai Phong Port. The European yard owner also claimed the Singaporean trader had not ever sent a representative to Europe for inspection and for complaining the goods quality.

From these evidences, it can be seen that the Seller has defrauded the Buyer very spectacularly, properly, sophisticatedly and quite perfectly in this transaction with a very simple and common logistics trick in the international maritime trade. In fact, it was a Switch B/L (change of bill of lading): after the goods had been loaded on the ship at a European port, they asked the carrier to change the name of the goods in the first original bill of lading, from E46 to the type ISRI 210-211 that they had committed to and the name of the shipper would be changed to their name, not that of the European yard owner as before, and other information such as loading port, port of discharge, ship name, quantity, weight, volume of goods, bill of lading number, date of issue of bill of lading and number of containers remain the same as the set of documents they had received from the European yard owner, which means the Singapore Seller applied quite proficiently the B/L Switch operation in normal logistics operations. This usually only takes a few lines of email to exchange with the carrier, as long as the Shipper requesting such a change has to commit himself to be responsible for the consequences of such changes.

Judgment of the arbitral tribunal

After many exchanges of views from different angles, some arbitrators participating in the trial of this dispute found that it was true that the Singapore Seller had violated the quality of the goods compared to the sales contract, but the Seller’s fraudulent acts were not governed by the law on commercial contracts, that is, outside the adjudication function of commercial arbitration. Therefore, the Arbitration Council, based on the sale and purchase contract and the quality inspection records, could only consider asking the Seller to compensate for the damaged goods (about 20%) that the buyer has inspected according to strict regulations in the contract and a few other reasonable costs, and the seller’s actions with signs of fraud through the B/L Switch operation of the seller had to be resolved in accordance with the law and jurisdiction. by other appropriate law enforcement agencies.

Advice

In order to prevent such scams, scrap metal importers and exporters need to clearly stipulate in their scrap import contracts that: Buyers have the right to appoint their own inspectors to review the quality of goods when they are loaded on board at the port of departure. Never think that because Vietnamese enterprises import under CFR or CIF conditions, everything at the port of departure does not need to be paid much attention. Regarding the terms of goods inspection at the port of destination, the Vietnamese Buyer absolutely never accepts to inspect the entire shipment of thousands of tons of scrap within a week after unloading at ports of Vietnam, because it is a challenging job- it is impossible to do inspection for thousands of tons of scrap.

Another thing that should be adequately noted is that it must be clearly stated in the contract that the scrap metal inspection should only be carried out by random selection with a maximum rate of not more than 10%. In contracts to sell scrap iron to Vietnamese enterprises, foreign traders often offer a penalty clause if the percentage of impurities in scrap exceeds the contract’s stipulation. This seems reasonable and acceptable at first glance, but when the dispute is adjudicated under Vietnam’s Commercial Law, the buyer’s side will be at a disadvantage due to Article 301 of Vietnam’s Commercial Law: once it is fined, a maximum fine is not more than 8% of the value of the damage.

Doosan Vina manufactures and exports 2,195 tons of fired heater to Thailand

Time 11/01/2021 at 16:09

On the morning of January 11, 2021, at Dung Quat Economic Zone, Quang Ngai province, Doosan Vina opened the New Year 2021 with the shipment of 2,195 tons of raw fuel heating support equipment under the TOP Fired Heater project for South Korea JNK Heaters customer after more than a year of production.

International sea transport in the first six months of 2021

Time 10/09/2021 at 17:01

Unprecedented increase in freight rates due to a shortage of containers; congestion incident in the Suez Canal; the pandemic of COVID-19 lasting since 2020 becoming more serious with the Delta variation and sweeping over countries in Asia as India, the South of China and Southeast Asian countries is causing shortage of stevedoring workers in ports, including those in the U.S; human resource crisis in the global maritime sector with the difficulty of providing adequate care for some 1.7m seafarers… These consecutive shocks have caused impacts to the sea transport market in the first six months of the year and direct impacts to Vietnam’s activities of production and import-export as well.

Hai Van 2: Value is not only in hundreds of thousands of safe traffic

Time 17/05/2021 at 10:15

According to information from Hai Van Tunnel Management and Operation Enterprise, from the date of operation of the Hai Van 2 tunnel up to now, with a complete tunnel system, each tube circulates one-way, 2-lane circulation has served about 700,000 conveniently transportation safely.

“Branding goes together with social responsibilities”

Time 14/09/2021 at 14:00

Bee Logistics has had a number of particular success on its 17-year progress of development and a number of remarkable milestones… When the whole country is fighting against the pandemic, Bee Logistics has had important contribution in the task of epidemic prevention, carried out social responsibilities with practical activities. Dinh Huu Thanh - President/General Director of Bee Logistics- shared his thoughts.

Farmers selling products on digital environment

Time 13/09/2021 at 14:15

Digital transformation in agriculture is a phrase that has been mentioned a lot recently when agriculture is one of eight fields of priority that the program of national digital transformation issued by the prime minister is implemented. Giving more support and helping aricultural production households to participate in e-commerce platforms to consume agricultural products, especially in the context of the pandemic of COVID-19 is one of the directions that gives back positive signals in the process of national digital transformation.

8 Surefire ways to navigate global supply chain upheaval

Time 13/09/2021 at 14:00

While the shortages of cleaning and paper supplies prevalent during most of 2020 have largely abated in many countries, numerous supply chain challenges remain. The pandemic showed how tenuous many supply chains already were.